Thomas Sowell is a Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institute and the author of A Personal Odyssey, The Vision of the Anointed, Ethnic America, and several other books. His essays have appeared in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, Time, Newsweek, Forbes, and Fortune and are syndicated in 150 newspapers. He lives in Stanford, California.
Preface
Preface
General principles, such as "justice" or "equality," are often passionately invoked in the
course of arguing about the issues of the day, but such terms usually go undefined and unexamined. Often much more
could be gained by scrutinizing what we ourselves mean by such notions than by trying to convince or overwhelm
others. If we understood what we were really saying, in many cases we might not say it or, if we did, we might
have a better chance of making our reasons understood by those who disagree with us.
The heady rush of rhetoric and visions are the stuff of everyday politics and everyday media discussion. That
makes it all the more important that, at some point, we step back and examine what it all means underneath the
froth or glitter. This book is an attempt to do that.
The ideas discussed here took shape over a long period of time. The title essay evolved out of a paper I gave
in St. Gallen, Switzerland, in 1982 on "Trade-Offs and Social Justice." By 1984, it was recast and elaborated
at great length in another paper called "Social Justice Reconsidered," which was circulated to various
people around the country, including Milton Friedman and Mancur Olson. Professor Friedman's typically incisive
criticisms were followed by the opinion that "it is well worth the effort required to put it in shape."
Professor Olson's comments were likewise critical and perhaps not quite as encouraging. I too understood the difficulties
of that draft, which was academic and radically different in form from what appears in this book.
Over the years, "Social Justice Reconsidered" evolved into "The Quest for Cosmic Justice,"
completely recast yet again, but still not finished a decade later. Nor was it certain that it ever would be finished,
given the various other projects I was involved in. However, in the spring of 1996, some particularly sophomoric
remarks by one of my Stanford colleagues not only provoked my anger but also convinced me that there was a real
need to untangle the kind of confusions that could lead any sensible adult to say the things he had said -- and
which all too many other people were saying. I went home and immediately resumed work on the essay on cosmic justice,
writing it now for the general public, rather than for an academic audience.
By the autumn of 1996, the new version was completed and I presented "The Quest for Cosmic Justice"
as a lecture in New Zealand. Much to my pleasant surprise, large excerpts from it were published in the country's
leading newspapers. This press coverage, as well as the enthusiastic reception of the talk by a non-academic audience,
convinced me that this was something that the general public would understand -- perhaps more readily than some
academics who are locked into the intellectual fashions of the day.
The other essays in this book also evolved over a period of years and within a similar framework of thought
that now gives them a collective coherence, even though they were written to stand alone individually. The central
ideas in "Visions of War and Peace" first appeared in an article of that title that I published in 1987
in the British journal Encounter. The current and much briefer version is now a section in the essay "The
Tyranny of Visions."
The generosity of Milton Friedman and the late Mancur Olson in criticizing the earlier, academically oriented
paper of mine is much appreciated, but of course they share no responsibility for any shortcomings of the present,
very different essay, aimed at a more general audience. In a truly just world, I would also have to acknowledge
my debt to my colleague whose sloppy thinking galvanized me into action. However, I shall not do so by name, in
deference to collegiality and to the libel laws in a litigious society.
Thomas Sowell Rose and Milton Friedman Senior Fellow
Hoover Institution
Stanford University
"No One Should Pronounce on Justice or Equality Again without Grappling with Thomas Sowell's Powerful Argument."* This is not a comforting book-it is a book about disturbing issues that are urgently important today and enduringly critical for the future. It rejects both "merit" and historical redress as principles for guiding public policy. It shows how "peace" movements have led to war and to needless casualties in those wars. It argues that "equality" is neither right nor wrong, but meaningless. The Quest for Cosmic Justice shows how confused conceptions of justice end up promoting injustice, how confused conceptions of equality end up promoting inequality, and how the tyranny of social visions prevents many people from confronting the actual consequences of their own beliefs and policies. Those consequences include the steady and dangerous erosion of the fundamental principles of freedom-and the quiet repeal of the American revolution.
Table of Contents
Contents Preface
I The Quest for Cosmic Justice
II The Mirage of Equality
III The Tyranny of Visions
IV The Quiet Repeal of the American Revolution
Notes
Index